Search This Blog

Thursday, March 31, 2022

DNA Q&A: GEDmatch

Re-pint from FamilyTree.com 

By Diahan Southard

Share to Pinterest

Q: Do I need GEDmatch?

A: There are traditionally three reasons people use GEDmatch: to find new matches, to use the tools, and to see segment data.

In the early days of autosomal DNA testing we had only three companies in play: AncestryDNA, Family Tree DNA and 23andMe. If you wanted to compare your results with someone who had tested at a different company, of just see if you had matches in a different company, you had to actually test at that company. Back when prices were $200 or $300 per test, that could get really pricey really fast. But then GEDmatch entered the scene in 2010 and offered us a FREE way to see matches who had tested at other companies. As long as you didn’t mind the rigmarole of downloading your data from one company, and uploading it into GEDmatch, it provided the perfect solution to our problem.

However, now that testing prices have plummeted, to even as low as $49 per test, testing at multiple companies is not necessarily out of budget. For those who still don’t want to shell out the extra cash, you can transfer into Family Tree DNA, MyHeritage and Living DNA and have full access to your match list for free! This means if you test at AncestryDNA or 23andMe, then transfer to the three just mentioned, you can be in 4 of the 5 genetic genealogy databases for just under $100.

But even if you aren’t in all of the companies, will you find new matches at GEDmatch? It is unlikely. If someone was genetic genealogist enough to transfer to GEDmatch, it is very likely that they also transferred to either FTDNA, MyHeritage or LivingDNA as well, right? So you can just find them at those companies without using GEDmatch.

But what about the tools?

GEDmatch does have a couple tools you won’t find in your testing company. A powerful tool for those seeking unknown parents (or others just out of curiosity) is the Are My Parents Related tool. GEDmatch also provides lots of different views of your ethnicity based on different algorithms. You can also discover what color your eyes are likely to be (in case you don’t have a mirror).

The biggest tool genetic genealogists feel they need from GEDmatch is the segment data that AncestryDNA is not providing. Aside from the fact that you don’t actually need segment data to determine a relationship, in order to get it you have to also convince all of your DNA cousins at Ancestry to transfer to GEDmatch as well.

So, while GEDmatch used to be a great place to meet and greet new cousins, much like the drive-in, its day has passed. Currently GEDmatch has a very different purpose: to help solve violent crimes. Regardless of your position on this topic, it is very important that we reeducate everyone in the community about the new purpose of GEDmatch, just to be clear about what new users are signing up for.

Monday, March 28, 2022

A Timely History of Time Zones

 Re-print from FamilyTree.com

By Andrew Koch
Share to Pinterest
The history of time zones heavily involves railroads, who created the first time zones in 1883.
The Standard Time Act in 1918 formally established four US time zones. This map (courtesy Wikimedia Commons and colorized by user:OwenBlacker) shows the railroads’ time zones five years earlier, in 1913.

Sick of having to change your watch when you travel? Puzzled as you make phone plans with family across the country? You’re not alone. On March 19, 1918, the US Congress passed the Standard Time Act, officially establishing the four time zones we have today and ending the “wild west” days of time management.

Let’s take a look at a brief history of time zones in the United States. The time zone map above shows the four zones as they were just a few years before their official adoption.

How Railroads Created Time Zones

Railroad companies first created time zones as a way of regulating schedules for their trains. Before the railroad boom of the 1800s, each town kept its own standard time, often based on the position of the sun.

But as transportation methods improved and travel times decreased, these inconsistencies created headaches for companies and passengers alike. How could a train leave Philadelphia at 10:25 am local time, travel for two hours, and arrive in Pittsburgh at 11:15 am local time? And was that train leaving at 10:25 Philadelphia time, or 10:25 Pittsburgh time? Safety was also a concern, as trains attempting to run on the same tracks at the same time could crash. To put it simply: Companies needed a way to literally make the trains run on time. The Great Western Railway in Great Britain came up with a solution first, implementing a standard “railway time” in its stations in 1840. By adopting one single time, the Great Western Railway could ensure its trains operated on the same time table. Conductors could also more easily coordinate which trains were running on which tracks at a given time, lowering the chances of a crash.

Time Zones Come to the US

Following from this early success, US companies began adopting their own railway times in the 1880s. They established four standard time zones for the continental United States in 1883.

However, many towns refused the changes, not wanting to sacrifice their independence for a corporate-mandated standard. Localities continued to keep their own time in addition to “railway time,” creating a dual time system that (if anything) made the issue worse.

The Standard Time Act of 1918

The federal Standard Time Act in 1918 put an end to these discrepancies. The act allowed the (now-defunct) Interstate Commerce Commission to create time zones. Though the boundaries have shifted over the decades, the four original continental US zones (Eastern, Central, Mountain and Pacific) remain. The legislation also temporarily established Daylight Savings Time in most of the United States, another temporal oddity.

The map above from 1913 shows the early versions of the four US time zones. Note how Michigan, Ohio, Indiana and many of the southern states have since transferred from Central Time to Eastern Time, presumably to be on the same time as heavily populated East Coast cities like New York and Washington, DC.

For more, check out David A. Fryxell’s in-depth history of time zones. His ebook The Best of History Matters is an excellent resource for learning more about your ancestors’ world. The book contains detailed histories of different aspects of daily life, from voting to weddings to blue jeans.

Last updated, March 2021.

5 Ideas to Get to Know the Females in Your Family Tree

By Sunny Jane Morton
Portrait of the Riley family.
Riley family. C.M. Bell, photographer. Washington, D.C. [between February 1894 and February 1901]. Retrieved from the Library of Congress.

In the past, women appeared in records with far less frequency than men, especially under their own names (rather than their husbands’). If you don’t already know who they married, it’s easy to lose track of women before or after their surnames changed. For these reasons, it often takes extra effort to identify and trace women throughout their entire lives. Try these 5 tasks to get to know the females on your family tree.

1. Interview a female relative

Request some time from an older woman in your family (mother, grandmother, aunt or sister) to sit down and chat about their lives, experiences and memories. If you can do this in-person, you’ll likely have a more meaningful experience. But if you need to talk via Skype or Google Hangouts, you can use software such as SnagIt to audio- or video-record the conversation.

Before the interview, share with your subject the topics you hope to discuss, and give her veto power over any she doesn’t want to talk about. Ask her if there’s anything (or anyone) she’d especially like to tell you about. Get permission to record the conversation for family history purposes. Express your willingness to turn off the recorder if there’s something she wants to say off-the-record (and then stick to your commitment).

A lot of things have changed in women’s lives in recent decades. Don’t forget to ask your female relative about the changes that have affected her the most—and what she thinks of them. You might also ask what she thinks has not changed, for the better or the worst. Listen carefully to her perspective and don’t judge her or try to get her to change her way of thinking. This is a time to appreciate her for who she is. Thank her sincerely for sharing her thoughts and feelings, whether you agree with them or not. Here are some additional tips on interviewing a relative.

Senior family members are often the best genealogy resource. Here are family history interview questions to ask to discover more about generations past.

2. Find your female ancestors in all available records

Especially as you go back further in time, information about the women in your family may be buried in records about the men. Dig into documents about the husband, siblings (especially brothers), parents and children. Look for her unknown surnames in relatives’ obituaries, her marriage record(s) and her children’s birth records (find more strategies here for learning a woman’s maiden name).

In older times, you may have to look even harder for women. Especially in the South, you may find brides mentioned in marriage bonds or the dower release portion of a land record. See if she appears as a widow in her husband’s military pension records. I once confirmed the identity of a woman by finding her mentioned in her brother’s delayed birth record, shown below (read about that here.)

delayed birth record
Delayed birth record

3. Tease apart multiple marriages and identify step relationships

Try to be accurate and precise about the marriages and family groups on your tree. Wherever possible, follow clues indicating that a parent is actually a step-parent; that a mother has more children you’ve already accounted for; or that someone was previously or subsequently married to someone else. Try to learn what you can about earlier or later marriages, including whether they ended by the partner’s death, divorce or bigamy.

Remember that when you attach records to individuals in your online trees, the sites may automatically attach children to step-parents who may appear as parents in census records. Untangle any mistakes that have been made by removing or clarifying relationships on your trees.

4. Follow all the daughters into adulthood

Your great-aunts and cousins deserve more than to be left dangling on a family tree with no further information than what you attach to their childhood census records. While you may understandably not want to put the same kind of effort into fully reconstructing the lives of collateral kin, try to at least account for them later in life.

family tree screenshot
Don’t leave your great-aunts and cousins hanging!

Did they marry? Move away or stay local? How and when did they die? Note what you’ve learned on their tree profiles. What you learn may affect your understanding of the ancestors you care most about. Learning that your great-grandma’s little sister became a Catholic nun or that her older sister helped raise her after their mama died certainly tells you more about that great-grandma, as well. You may come to recognize patterns, too:

“Researching family and friends can reveal patterns that you won’t notice if you keep a narrow focus only on your direct ancestors. Naming patterns or physical traits might emerge, such as several members of the family being left-handed or sharing an eye color. Other patterns might include occupations, military service, religion, or even reveal social status, class or education level.”

–Vanessa Wieland in “Cluster and Collateral Research to Find Ancestors

5. Pay attention to maternal DNA

If you’ve taken an autosomal DNA test, sort your matches to learn more about mom’s side of the family. In AncestryDNA’s updated Matching experience, you can now see whether someone matches you on your mother’s or father’s side (assuming it has been identified):

researching maternal dna
Researching maternal DNA

You can also take an mtDNA test to learn more about your direct maternal line. “Because we all have our mother’s mtDNA, anyone can take an mtDNA test to learn about maternal-line origins—and sometimes about family history,” writes Diahan Southard in this article. “Your origins information is provided in the form of an mtDNA haplogroup assignment. This is just a set of letters and numbers, such as H1a1a2b, that describes where your ancestor may have been thousands of years ago. You also get a list of people who have the same mtDNA profile as you do. Unlike autosomal DNA matches, your mtDNA matches don’t necessarily share a recent ancestor with you. Because mtDNA rarely mutates, there’s no good way to tell if a match is your second cousin or your 22nd cousin.”

If you test early enough in March, you may have your results back by Mother’s Day. (Family Tree DNA, the only major vendor of mtDNA testing for genealogy, requires 6-8 weeks to process your test.)

Thursday, March 24, 2022

The Alphabet Soup of Army Rations

Have you ever wondered what the difference is between C-Rations and K-Rations? During WWII, US military officials had to find a way to feed the troops when they weren’t near a mess hall. Rations were prepackaged meals, easy to prepare, and intended to be eaten in the field. The Unit History of the 63rd Infantry Division breaks down some of the different types of rations that fueled troops and helped Allies win the war. 

American journalist Ernie Pyle eating C-Rations

A-Ration: A-rations were the most preferred by US fighting forces and consisted of fresh, refrigerated, or frozen foods. The meals were prepared in kitchens or field kitchens and generally served in permanent dining halls.

B-Ration: B-Rations were prepared by trained cooks in a field kitchen while on the move. Ingredients consisted of canned and dehydrated foods that did not require refrigeration. Thus, the food could be kept in a truck or wagon for months without spoiling.

C-Ration: Often called C-Rats, these rations were designed for individual combat troops and consisted of precooked food in tinplate cans that opened with a key. Initially, officials calculated that C-Rations would only be consumed for no more than three days at a time and produced just three varieties. As fighting forces relied more on C-Rations, they quickly tired from the lack of variety, and the military eventually expanded the offerings. C-Rations could be eaten cold but tasted better heated and included an entrée, such as pork and beans, or spaghetti and meat sauce. They also contained biscuits or crackers, gum or candy, and cigarettes.

Soldiers load trucks with rations 1944

D-Ration: The D-Ration was a heat-resistant, fortified chocolate bar intended to provide high energy in a small package that soldiers could carry in a pocket. Formulated with help from Hershey Food Corporation, the 1,800 calorie D-Ration contained concentrated chocolate, vitamins, and other ingredients meant to sustain a soldier during an emergency. It did not taste appealing, preventing soldiers from nibbling on the bar unless necessary.

K-Rations

K-Ration: Originally developed for paratroopers by a University of Minnesota physiologist Ancel Keys, the K-Ration had lightweight but durable packaging. Three K-Ration meals provided 2,830 calories but proved inadequate for some soldiers who required more calories per day based upon their strenuous output. A sample supper ration included a meat product, biscuits, a chocolate bar or caramels, bouillon, coffee, sugar, wooden spoon, cigarettes, chewing gum, and a packet of toilet paper.

In addition to the rations above, the military had additional field rations and modified existing rations throughout the war. What stories have you heard about WWII military rations? Search Fold3® to learn more about military rations and see our complete WWII records collection.

The Genealogist’s Guide to Church Records

 

The Genealogist’s Guide to Church Records

By Sunny Jane Morton

In 1926, roughly half the US population belonged to one of about 230,000 religious congregations across the country. Some churchgoers also attended Sunday schools, church socials, service auxiliaries and revivals; and sent their children to church-sponsored schools.

Such vigorous worship communities often produced vigorous records. Among them were membership lists, baptismal registers, marriage records and lists of deaths and burials. Maiden names, ages or dates of birth, relatives’ names and relationships, and prior or subsequent residences (including overseas birthplaces) may be sprinkled throughout these records.

Church records aren’t always easy to find or access, but online resources make this task easier. Online sources may help you identify an ancestor’s probable congregation. Web searches may lead you to sources of published or microfilmed versions and even digitized online records. This guide will get you started.

Types of church records

Before you set off in search of church records, consider when it’s worth searching for them. Records pre-dating the Civil War are more likely to be written freeform in blank books or on loose sheets, often with scant detail. Baptisms and marriages are the life events most commonly found, with the date of the event, witnesses or godparents, officiant, and (for children’s baptisms) names of parents. Deaths and/or burials were more likely recorded if the church had its own burial ground. Protestant faiths often created periodic roll calls of members or a master membership list with infrequent but valuable details like a spouse’s name or death date noted.

In the later 1800s, churches began using registers pre-printed with columns. Details varied by faith, congregation and even the scribe. Many Protestant faiths kept membership ledger books with separate lists of ministers and church officers, baptisms (with parents’ names for children), marriages (often with the couple’s residences) and deaths (sometimes with burial information). The dates of these events, officiants and sometimes witnesses were recorded.

Members of many Protestant denominations who migrated received letters of transfer admitting them to the new church. Membership ledgers may have notations such as “admitted by letter,” along with the previous city or church. When someone moved out, you may see “dismissed to” or “disposed of” with the destination and/or date. Rarely, letters of transfer survive in church administrative files.

Some Protestant faiths, such as Lutherans and Methodists, recorded more details than others. Baptist records are typically sparse. Record content also may vary based on beliefs or practices. For example, Quakers don’t baptize; therefore, they don’t have baptismal records. But records of Quaker marriages often include the names of everyone in attendance, the bride’s and groom’s residences and their parents’ names and residences (or an indication the parents were deceased).

Catholic parishes (the term for a local congregation) didn’t generally keep membership lists, but they did register sacraments—often in Latin and sometimes, for churches with large immigrant memberships, in a foreign language. Most often you’ll find records for:

  • Baptism, often performed within a day or two of birth, with the date, godparents, child’s parents and the parents’ birthplace. Later sacraments in that child’s life also might be noted here, too, even if they occurred in another church. 
  • Confirmation, often received as a young teen, recorded as a simple list of those who received it and the date. Use this record to confirm a family’s residence at that time and participation in church life. More recent records may mention the place and date of baptism

Example: Catholic Baptismal Register


Citation for this record: St. Joseph’s Church (Fremont, OH). “Diocese of Toledo, Ohio, Catholic Parish Records, 1796-2004.” Digital images, Ancestry.com: accessed 19 April 2016. Original images from FamilySearch.org.
  1. The columns shown are for last name, date of event, particulars of baptism and additional comments.
  2. These records are in Latin; even Latin forms of names may be used. “Guilel” is an abbreviation of Gulielmus, Latin for William.
  3. The translated baptismal record reads, “I, the undersigned, baptized Appoloniam Helaram, born 15 Ap[ril], of Jos[eph] Steinlein from place [blank] and Cath[erine] Gunther from place [blank], married. Godparents were Jos[eph] Steiner and Appolonia Gunther.”
  4. Comments include a note about Appolonia’s marriage, specifying her spouse’s name, the date and parish. Check that parish for records of the marriage and children’s baptisms.

Marriage and possible banns (formal announcements), if they were read prior to the marriage. Look for the couple’s name, parents’ names, witnesses and officiant’s name. More recent records may indicate baptismal place and date.

Extreme unction or last rites, performed for the dying. Look for notes about the dates of death and burial, burial place, and sometimes age at death.

Holy orders and taking of vows, for those who became priests or nuns. (Look for additional records in an archive for the religious order the person joined.)

Also look for denominational newspapers. Methodists published regional versions of the Christian Advocate (for example, the New York Christian Advocate or the Nashville Christian Advocate). Several Catholic dioceses published newspapers or newsletters, too. Many of these had limited runs in the late 1800s and included obituaries of members.

Identifying the right church

On the eve of the Revolutionary War, more than half of those in the English colonies were either Congregationalists (mostly in New England) or Anglicans (Church of England, dominant in the South). Others were Presbyterian, Dutch Reformed and in much smaller numbers, Quakers, Baptists, Catholics, Methodists and Jews. Spanish and French colonists were largely Catholic; a significant minority of French colonists were Huguenots.

That religious picture changed dramatically during the following century. Anglicans and Congregationalists lost government sponsorship and popularity. More experiential faiths took their place. By 1860, half the congregations in the US were Methodist and a quarter were Baptist. Another 10 percent were Catholic—a number that would grow as more Catholic immigrants arrived.

To determine what church might have records of your ancestors, make an informed guess based on these factors:

Family lore: Ask older relatives what churches family members attended throughout their lives. Check with distant cousins, too, especially those who still live near an ancestral hometown.

Records: An ancestor’s faith or specific church might be specified (or at least hinted at) in nonreligious records. Watch for a religion or church mentioned in an obituary or associated with a burial place (keeping in mind that a churchyard burial may have represented the religious wishes of other relatives, not the deceased). Research the affiliation of ministers who married or buried your ancestors. Look up the meaning of symbols on tombstones. Look for biographical details in funeral programs, county histories and other documents.

Transitions: The religious choices of one generation don’t always agree with the preceding one. Switching to a different faith might happen with marriage or migration away from relatives or to a place where the old faith didn’t have a foothold. As you trace immigrant ancestors, be aware that some ethnic groups assimilated faster than others. Watch for a transitional generation whose more “American” naming patterns or dress are distinct from those of the previous generation. This may be a key time to look for clues pointing to an “Old World” religion.

Ethnic group: Immigrants often brought their country’s dominant faiths. English were often Anglican (a denomination that became the Episcopal church in the United States); Scots-Irish, Presbyterian; and Scandinavians, Lutheran. Irish, Italians, Spanish, French and many Eastern Europeans often were Catholic. Germans had the most variety: Catholic, Lutheran, Reformed, Jewish and many smaller sects.

Conversely, members of many religious groups—English Quakers or French Huguenots, for example—came to the United States because they didn’t agree with their national faith. Consult history books to learn the overall religious picture of your ancestor’s ethnic or national group, including dissenting or “nonconformist” sects that migrated during that time period.

Immigrants from the same place and who shared a religion often settled together in America. Those initial religious cultures evolved with the changing times and residents. A region of the South that was primarily Anglican during one generation may have become mostly Methodist or Baptist within a few generations. Research local history to learn about these patterns.

Proximity

The nearest reasonable option may have determined a family’s place of worship. Many Congregationalists who went west from New England joined Presbyterian churches, which had a similar culture. Migrating German Lutherans may have joined ranks with local Reformed or similar German sects. City directories and neighborhood maps showing property ownership or local landmarks can help you identify the churches nearest your ancestors.

Some Catholic immigrants didn’t attend the parish nearest their home. In the late 1800s and early 1900s, ethnic parishes served German, Irish, Italian, Slovak and other Catholics who wanted to worship in their own languages. Local histories or a Catholic diocesan archivist (see below) can tell you about local parishes that served your family’s ethnicity.

Example: Methodist Sunday School Register

Citation for this record: Calvary United Methodist Church (Keyport, NJ). “New Jersey, Calvary United Methodist Church Records, 1832-2003.” Digital images, FamilySearch: accessed 19 April 2016.
  1. On continuing pages, the year may appear in an abbreviated format, such as 81 for 1881.
  2. Prob likely stands for “probationer,” a probationary member. Look for these names with further information on a probationer’s list in the register book.
  3. This migration information is a clue to look for individuals in their new places.
  4. If someone was “received into membership,” look for his or her entries in the member list in elsewhere in the register book.
  5. Notes such as ”discontinued as unworthy” or “discontinued—drunkenness” reveal more than just whether a person was present at Sunday school.

Accessing church records

Once you’ve identified a possible ancestral church, it’s time to start looking for its membership or sacramental records. These may exist in original manuscript, microfilmed, published and/or even digitized format.

Although Ancestry.com and FamilySearch have selected church records (including Quaker records on the former), for the most part, these records aren’t online. But you can start your search with your favorite web browser. Search for the name of the church if you know it, along with the denomination, city and state. As desired, add terms such as records, baptisms or marriages to narrow search results.

Browse search results for websites of churches. Also watch for any mention of records in online manuscript finding aids, genealogy website databases, on microfilm or in published format at a library (more about these below).

If the local church exists and has a website, your search should bring it up. If you can’t find one, search for the name of the denomination and the phrase “church locator.” Most denominations have online tools to help you find their churches in specific locales.

Look for history information on the website to confirm that this church existed during your ancestor’s life, was in the right place and, if applicable, matched your family’s ethnicity. Most congregational websites don’t mention whether they have old records, but it’s worth browsing the site to see.

You should at least find contact information for the church office. Send a brief inquiry about membership or sacramental records for the time period in question and the procedure for ordering them. Ask whether they would direct you to records if they exist elsewhere. Be polite and patient. Church offices aren’t obligated to fulfill genealogical requests. Mention your willingness to pay for a researcher’s time or to make a donation to the church.

Your ancestor’s congregation may have dissolved or merged with another one. In that case, conduct a web search for a denominational archive. Consult the toolkit on the previous page for a starter list. Some churches maintain a central archive or have archival collections at universities. Other churches have regional archives, such as Methodist conferences and Catholic dioceses. These may hold old records of congregations within their boundaries. Contact archivists about how to access historical records from the church and time period in question.

Tip: When requesting copies of records from churches and religious archives, be respectful and patient. Church offices aren’t obligated to help genealogical researchers.

If the denomination itself doesn’t seem to exist anymore, consult a denominational family tree like the ones at the Association of Religion Data Archives website. You’ll learn important details. For example, Congregational churches now exist under the banner of the United Church of Christ. This may help you to locate existing successor churches or contact an appropriate denominational archive.

The Family History Library (FHL) in Salt Lake City has many church records on microfilm. On the FamilySearch website, click Search, then Catalog. Search by place: Start typing the town, city, county or state, then choose from the dropdown menu that appears. In your search results, click Church Records. You’ll see a list of the FHL’s church records holdings for that place; click each one for details on the type of record and time period covered.

Some church records end up in private archives, too. Watch web search results for online finding aids or record collection descriptions. Use Archive Grid, an online catalog listing millions of records, to search for archives near your ancestor’s home. Also conduct a targeted search for published and/or microfilmed congregational records. Start with WorldCat, an online catalog with over 2 billion items in libraries worldwide. Enter the same types of search terms as previously described.

Besides membership and sacramental registers, archives’ collections of church records may include church histories, denominational newspapers, administrative minutes, changes in membership status and occasionally members’ significant life events. Separate records may cover women’s or other service auxiliaries. Financial records, including itemized donation lists, also may mention your relatives.

If you find index-only versions of records, try to track down the originals. They’ll expose any errors in the indexed information and provide additional information that wasn’t in the index. Some Catholic sacramental records are considered confidential. Church records are released at the discretion of the record custodian, whether it’s a local priest or diocesan archivist. If you can’t get photocopies of a record, you might be able to at least receive a certificate with basic sacramental information transcribed onto it. Request that every piece of information on the record be provided, not just what the certificate has space for.

Chronicling America can help you identify denominational newspapers to research. Click on the site’s US Newspaper Directory, 1690-Present to search for denominational titles. The Language, Ethnicity Press and Labor Press pulldown menus have options such as Anabaptist, Jewish and Catholic Labor Unions. Also try keyword searches like Catholic diocese or Lutheran. Click on a search result to look for microfilmed holdings you might borrow through interlibrary loan, or print holdings at libraries that may provide obituary searches.

Clues in church records

Church histories may have lists of members, substantial donors, churchyard burials or clergy. See whether mention is made of original church records still extant at that time. Scan the text to learn more about the religious community to which your family belonged. Other local or county histories may include historical sketches of the church, too.

Church records can solve several types of family history mysteries. They can provide evidence of vital events when government records conflict, weren’t created, or are missing. For some times and places, church records may provide the most likely or even the only source to mention births, marriages and deaths.

Tip: Don’t use a baptismal date as a surrogate for a birth date without evidence that it was an infant baptism.

They can resolve mysteries such as parents’ names, a woman’s maiden or married surname, the “illegitimate” circumstances of a child’s birth, an immigrant’s overseas birthplace, or a family’s previous or subsequent residence. They even can help you reconstitute a family group with all siblings, including those who died young and would otherwise go unnoticed. They can tell you about women and minorities, who were underrepresented in other records of the day. Finally, church records may give you a better understanding of your ancestor’s religious life and community.

When you come across records that require translation, try Google Translate for a single word or phrase. The FamilySearch wiki includes several foreign-language lists of common genealogical words. In the wiki search box, enter the name of the language and word list. Published genealogical guides for various ethnic or language groups may also include important genealogical words or phrases.

Fast Facts

  • Records begin: generally with establishment of an individual congregation
  • Jurisdiction where kept: individual churches’ administrative offices; denominational archives; government, university and private libraries and archives
  • Key details: dates and places of birth, baptism, marriage, death and burial; sometimes names of family members, migration places and dates
  • Search terms: name of denomination, church and/or congregation; plus the place and records, baptisms or marriages
  • How to find in the FamilySearch catalog: Under Search, select Catalog. Enter the place in the Places search box, then look under the Church Records category.
  • Associated/substitute records: records of birth, marriage, death and burial

A version of this article appeared in the September 2016 issue of Family Tree Magazine.

Monday, March 21, 2022

How to Research Orphaned and Adopted Children in Your Genealogy

By Sunny Jane Morton and Judy G. Russell
Black and white photo of two young boys who were orphaned by the Titanic's sinking.
“Photo taken before the ‘orphans’ of the Titanic were fully identified. The boys are French brothers Michel (age 4) and Edmond Navratil (age 2).” Their nicknames were Lolo and Mamon. (Source: Library of Congress via Flickr)

Legal adoption by loving new parents wasn’t common until the past century or so. Before that, orphaned American children may have been taken in by relatives or neighbors, bound into servitude, sent to orphanages or even shipped far away on a train. When children lost even one parent, they were vulnerable to being placed in new homes. Their fates depended largely on the time period and luck.

So how can you determine what may have happened to the families of children who suddenly show up on (or disappear from) your family tree? Here are five possible scenarios for what happened—and the paperwork that may help you piece together the stories.

Taken In By Other Family

It’s a timeless practice for relatives, friends or neighbors to care for orphaned children. But laws and attitudes about this practice—even what it meant to be orphaned—have changed over time. From colonial times to the mid-1800s, children were legally considered orphans if just their father had died. So a child referred to in legal documents as an orphan may have had a living mother. She, however, had few legal rights over her children or their property.

When a family of means lost its father, courts typically appointed a legal guardian to watch over the children’s inheritance until they came of age. The guardian was usually the child’s closest male relative who wouldn’t personally benefit if something happened to the child. Children often remained under the daily care of their mother, if she was alive and the estate provided sufficiently for the family. Look for records of guardianship appointments and related surety bonds in the county court that had jurisdiction, such as the county, orphan’s or probate court (the FamilySearch wiki article on that county may describe court jurisdictions). FamilySearch may have microfilmed records; search the catalog by place, adding the keyword guardian. Otherwise, contact the court directly.

If neither able-bodied mother nor family fortune existed, then family, friends or neighbors often stepped in. This wouldn’t have generated formal adoption paperwork. Evidence of their caregiving might appear in a census listing showing the child living with a new family, in correspondence, or in the child’s inclusion in the new parents’ wills or estate paperwork.

Labor Contracts and Apprenticeships

When no relatives or friends stepped forward, communities took over the care of orphans. This often was also the case for children whose mothers couldn’t adequately support them and whose fathers were unknown or absent. Taxpayers expected even young children who became public charges to work to earn their keep. A common solution from colonial times until after the Civil War was to “bind out” children into labor contracts until they reached adulthood.

Indenturing and apprenticing children could be both voluntary and involuntary. Two-parent families often willingly contracted their child’s labor to a master for a proscribed time. In exchange, the child received room, board and—for apprentices—vocational training. When the contract was up, the master provided “freedom dues,” often in the form of cash, clothing and tools.

Local officials could force children who became public charges, or who were at risk of becoming so because of poverty or illegitimacy, into indentures and apprenticeships. In the 1700s and early 1800s, elected overseers or superintendents of the poor in townships, cities or counties often made these decisions. They recorded their activities in county commissioners’ records or in separate account or logbooks. Surviving records may be in government offices or archives. Search for microfilmed records in the FamilySearch catalog by place, then look for a poorhouses, poor law or similar category. In Colonial Virginia, Anglican vestrymen documented binding-outs in parish minutes; start your search for surviving records at the Library of Virginia.

Binding-out and apprenticeship contracts were filed in local courts that had jurisdiction over orphans and estates. Contracts might name the indentured party, master and terms of the agreement. Later court records may show the conclusion, extension or breaking of the contract. Locate these records in the same way suggested for guardianships. Apprenticeship and binding-out records aren’t often found online, but Ancestry.com has a database of about 8,000 such names for Virginia.

African-American children were disproportionately impacted by the binding-out system. Before the Civil War, some Southern states allowed courts wide latitude to bind out free black children to white masters. After the Civil War, Southern states enacted new laws that favored indenturing children of color to white masters, with preference given to their former slaveholders. Justifications for indentures included parental neglect, poverty, unemployment or an act of bad behavior by at least one parent.

Binding-out contracts should first appear in local court records, along with follow-up efforts by parents to reclaim their children. After emancipation, when courts turned a deaf ear, thousands of African-American parents enlisted help from the Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen and Abandoned Lands (“Freedmen’s Bureau”). Start with its field office reports for information about labor contracts and disputes.

More than 1.8 million Freedmen’s Bureau records are newly indexed. Search them at DiscoverFreedmen.org or among more than 125 related databases at FamilySearch. Ancestry has a database of field office reports for multiple states. Find a directory to scattered indexes of labor contracts at The Freedmen’s Bureau Online.

Case Study: Mary Lackey

She appeared out of nowhere. In the 1860 US census, 12-year-old Mary Lackey lives in the North Carolina household of Benjamin and Luranna Gilbert. Like all censuses before 1880, the record doesn’t state any relationship between household members. The 1850 census is no help, either: That year, the Gilberts were a childless couple in their 30s.

Who, then, was Mary Lackey?

Court records have the answer. On the 14th of April, 1851, the Yancey County, NC, Court of Common Pleas entered this order: “Ordered by Court that … Mary Lacky aged about one years old … minor heir of Elizabeth Lacky be bound unto Benjamin Gilbert until she attain to the age of 18 years … .”

So Mary Lackey was the Gilbert’s young servant. She was just one year old when she was contractually bound to them.

Close up of a record listing Mary Lackey.
Mary Lackey’s unexplained appearance with the Gilbert family in the 1860 census of Yancy County, NC, was a cue to look for information about her birth. Records of the county Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions (on FHL microfilm No. 571520) in 1851 revealed that she was bound out to the Gilberts. That record gives Mary’s age, “about four years,” and names her mother, Elizabeth.

Orphanages and Children’s Homes

Almshouses existed in colonial America as early as the 1650s in New York, 1662 in Boston and 1702 in Philadelphia. Poor farms and poorhouses became more numerous by the early 1800s, particularly in cities. These served primarily widows and children. During the following decades, most counties established separate children’s homes. Charities also founded institutions for special populations, such as foundling hospitals for infants and unmarried mothers, and segregated homes for minority children.

Orphan boys standing in a line inNew York City.
Many children in orphanages, such as the New York City facility that cared for these “inmates” in 1913, had one or both living parents. Families might temporarily sign over children when unable to support them financially.

The Civil War (and later, the Spanish-American War) caused thousands more children to become orphaned or indigent. Several states, counties and towns built homes especially for the children of sailors and soldiers. The Grand Army of the Republic created similar facilities.

Placement in an orphanage was often temporary. Parents or extended family might sign over custody of children until they could get back on their feet. In fact, the majority of children eventually returned to their homes. Children who were surrendered permanently became wards of the state.

If you think a child may have been placed in an orphanage, look for him first in the US census. As early as 1850, he should appear as an “inmate” of a home, listed alongside other residents. When you find children in an institution in the 1880 census, also look for their enumeration in the Defective, Dependent and Delinquent special census schedule, available for several states on Ancestry.com. Censuses of homeless and institutionalized children may include information about their parents, such as country or state of birth. If you can determine what facility housed a child, try to locate records. Search online for the facility’s name and location and look for:

  • Record indexes on websites such as Ancestry.com or USGenWeb articles about the history of the institution, which may point to surviving records.
  • Manuscript finding aids for original record collections at archives.
  • The FamilySearch catalog also includes hundreds of microfilmed orphanage records. Find relevant ones by running a keyword search with the name of the facility or the word orphanage and the location.

Any surviving orphanage records are probably rich in detail. Records may include intake registers, surrenders of children (also called quit-claims) and even death and burial records for those who passed away in the home. Some individual files may be restricted, especially those that contain medical data. But you may at least be able to confirm a residence along with some family information.

Orphan Trains

Not everyone was a fan of the orphanage system. Some reformers thought children should be placed with families, preferably in rural areas, rather than spending their lives in regimented orphanages that didn’t adequately prepare them for adulthood. The most famous (or infamous) approach to this early version of foster care was the orphan train movement.

In the 1850s, an estimated 30,000 children in New York City were homeless. The Children’s Aid Society in New York struggled to care for them. Society leaders believed children faced brighter futures with rural families. The society began shipping children by train to mostly the Midwest and West. Willing families, responding to newspaper ads, showed up at the railway station, chose a child and filled out contracts to shelter and educate them. Older children would be paid for their work. In theory, the society tracked the welfare of each child, but in practice this proved impractical. Records created at the time and afterward showed that many children did well and some didn’t.

Nearly every US state, as well as Canada and Mexico, received orphan train children, with Indiana receiving the most. The New York Foundling Hospital, New York Juvenile Asylum and Orphan Asylum Society of the City of New York all placed children on orphan trains, as did institutions in Chicago, Boston and Minnesota. All told, about a quarter million American and Canadian children rode orphan trains in the last half of the 1800s and through 1929.

Today, a network of orphan train riders and their families researches their roots via the Orphan Train Heritage Society, housed at the National Orphan Train Complex in Concordia, Kan. The official archive of the Children’s Aid Society is at the New York Historical Society Museum & Library. The collection is rich in historical material and correspondence; however, much material from individual case files is restricted. Research services are available for those who can’t visit the library themselves. Find contact information for several institutions that participated in orphan trains here.

Start researching an orphan train relative with his or her appearance in federal and state censuses. Look for him both in institutions before placement and in homes afterward. Ancestry.com has a database of about 5,000 children who lived in Children’s Aid Society facilities during various state or federal censuses. Also research local newspapers for ads or articles about the arrival of the train. Several state-level orphan train groups and regional research facilities gather information about riders in their areas.

Adoption

Formal legal adoption is a modern practice that didn’t begin in the United States until Massachusetts passed a statute allowing for it in 1851. This law, quickly copied by other states, required the court to supervise adoptions and gave adopted children the right to inherit from the adoptive parents. By the end of the 19th century, laws generally required that courts consider the good moral character of the adoptive parents and their ability to support and educate the child. Informal adoptions, though, continued well into the 20th century.

Adoption records were public everywhere until 1917, when Minnesota passed the first law making them confidential. This protected the records from public scrutiny but left them open to adopting parents and adoptees themselves. By the mid-1940s, confidentiality gave way to secrecy: Many young girls were sent to homes for unwed mothers where they were pressured to surrender their babies for adoption. Records were sealed, and a new amended birth certificate issued listing the adoptive parents as the parents. Even the adoptee was unable to obtain a copy of the original record.

The change from open court records to confidential records to secret records makes adoption research a real challenge. Changes in access laws, however, have opened some states’ adoption records to both adoptees and members of birth families under certain circumstances. Essentially, all states allow adopted persons access to nonidentifying information once they reach adulthood. That may include the birth parents’ ages and general physical information, race, ethnicity, religion, medical history, education, occupations and existence of other children.

Some states disclose identifying details about adoptees and birth parents, often only with mutual consent. Roughly 20 states give some or all adoptees access to their original birth certificates. In still other states, adoptees and birth families must use confidential intermediaries to obtain information. If you’re looking for your birth family or that of a parent or grandparent, find summaries of states’ current access laws online.

Under the State Resources menu, choose State Statutes, scroll to Adoption topics and choose the specific subtopics. See also the American Adoption Congress website.

DNA testing is a relatively new tool available for finding biological relatives. Start with autosomal DNA tests, available from AncestryDNA, MyHeritage DNA23andMe and Family Tree DNA (look for the Family Finder test). Results can link adoptees to family members who’ve also tested, and verify biological relationships hinted at in paper trails. Tests work best when matching close relatives, and are least reliable for fifth cousins and beyond. Understand that the process is emotional for adoptees, their parents and birth families (who may not be aware of the adoption). Approach matches—and your own feelings—with a great deal of sensitivity.

 A version of this article appeared in the December 2016 issue of Family Tree Magazine.

Saturday, March 19, 2022

Family Reunion Planning Checklist Free Download

 

Family Reunion Planning Checklist Free Download

By Family Tree Editors

Planning a family reunion? Use this handy timeline and checklist to guide your decisions and strategies, for both before and after the event.

One Year –18 Months Before the Reunion

  • Recruit a planning committee
  • Schedule committee meetings
  • Assign responsibilities (such as attendance, finance, communication, venue, food, activities, etc.)
  • Set a date and place (survey relatives if need be)
  • Gather relatives’ contact information or update contact list
  • Collect starter money (if a first-time reunion) or evaluate balance from the last reunion
  • Set a budget (estimate costs, determine admission price)
  • Open a reunion bank account (if you don’t have one)
  • Set up a reunion website and/or Facebook page
  • Send “save the date” announcement 
  • Determine a theme
  • Brainstorm activities, entertainment and food based on
    the theme
  • Investigate any events permits or other requirements

12 Months Before

  • Book the reunion venue
  • Book a caterer, if using
  • Book a professional photographer/videographer, or ask a relative to shoot photos and video
  • Book entertainment, if using
  • Reserve other services, such as tables and chairs or site clean-up
  • Apply for permits
  • Prepare map/directions to event site

9 Months Before

  • Design the invitation and tickets (if using)
  • Order mementos and souvenirs
  • Set up an email template for your registration confirmation message
  • Begin preparing personal histories, slideshows, videos or other reunion handouts or displays
  • Note milestones to acknowledge at the reunion, such as anniversaries, graduations, etc.
  • Send a reminder announcement
  • Look for sales of non-perishable supplies, such as decorations, plates, cups and napkins

6 Months Before

  • Plan decorations, displays and centerpieces
  • Send official invitation
  • Update address list as needed; continue to contact non-responders and potential attendees
  • Arrange for door prizes and game prizes
  • Prepare door prize drawing tickets
  • Book accommodations for traveling guests, if necessary

3 Months Before

  • Send reminder announcement (include enticing reunion details)
  • Get event insurance as required
  • Determine venue layout
  • Make name tags
  • Make table centerpieces and other decorations
  • Prepare photo collage
  • Prepare signage (marking the venue, registration area, drinks, bathrooms, etc.)
  • Finalize schedule
  • Designate event emcee
  • Prepare announcements
  • Prepare printed program

1 Month Before

  • Finalize personal histories, memory albums, slideshows, videos, etc., and order professional copies as necessary
  • Update attendees list
  • Assign dishes for potluck
  • Continue attendee recruitment efforts
  • Send reminder announcement
  • Recruit helpers for set-up and clean-up
  • Inventory items needed on-site and who is responsible for bringing each one
  • Prepare a reunion survey
  • Make name tags as needed
  • Shop for nonperishable supplies

2 Weeks Before

  • Send reminders or tickets if using them
  • Finalize attendance
  • Prepare list of paid guests (if applicable)
  • Confirm event details with all vendors and suppliers
  • Finalize announcements and deliver to emcee
  • Verify delivery of donated door prizes
  • Finalize and print any handouts and labels
  • For potluck, confirm who’s bringing what

1 Week Before

  • Update attendance list with last minute guests
  • Finalize list of paid attendees
  • Prepare name tags or registration packets
  • Set contingency plans for weather or other unexpected events
  • Give meal count to caterer (if using one)
  • Shop for perishables
  • Prepare final payment to venue and vendors
  • Confirm room set up and equipment arrangements with venue (if applicable)
  • Prepare checklist for the day of the reunion

1 Day before

  • Pick up beverages, ice and food (cake, cookie trays, sandwich trays, etc.)
  • Prepare food and drinks as needed
  • Deliver supplies to venue if possible

Day of reunion

  • Bring reunion day supplies (including checkbook) and checklist for the day
  • Set up food and drinks
  • Set up decorations and activities
  • Have fun and enjoy the day!
  • Clean up and pack items
  • Retrieve supplies

After the Reunion

  • Send survey (if not distributed at event)
  • Finalize photo book and or video with photographer/videographer
  • Send memory albums and other handouts to those who paid but didn’t attend
  • Send thank you notes and follow up letters
  • Close bank account once all checks have cleared, or keep open with a minimal balance for the next reunion
  • Store reunion supplies in convenient location
  • Evaluate survey responses
  • Meet with committee to discuss successes and pitfalls
  • Send regular updates via a family website, social media, email and or mailings
  • Update contact list
  • Recruit planning committee volunteers for the next reunion

Thursday, March 17, 2022

What is a DD-214 Form?: A Section-by-Section Look

By George G. Morgan
DD 214 form with American flag and military uniform in the background.

Beginning in 1950, the Department of Defense issued DD-214 forms, also called Certificates of Release or Discharge from Active Duty. As the document’s longer name implies, each service member received a DD-214 upon his or her discharge from the United States Armed Forces. The form includes a verified record of the service member’s active and reserve duty, making it a valuable genealogical record. The Department of Veterans Affairs and employers used the document as proof of military service for veteran benefits and employment purposes, respectively.

The form replaced the WD AGO Forms and NAVPERS (Naval Personnel) discharge documents. (Those who served in the Army National Guard or Air National Guard received separate documentation.) A fire in 1973 at a National Archives center in St. Louis destroyed most Army and Air Force personnel records from the mid-20th century—making DD-214 forms critical in documenting military service.

Below is a DD-214 form from 1963, with annotations that will help you understand information in each column. Note that the person’s name has been redacted for privacy.

DD-214 forms can provide several crucial details about your ancestor's military service. Here's how to use one.

1. Personal Data

Details listed in DD-214 forms include the individual’s full name, service number, rank at discharge, place and date of birth, race, gender and marital status. The document also contains a physical description of the person and some background information about his or her education. Each piece of data can point you to additional records.

2. Transfer or Discharge Data

Here, you’ll find information on why the government issued this form. For example, the class of discharge or separation indicates the circumstances surrounding the person’s discharge: Honorable, General, Bad Conduct (i.e., court-martial) or Dishonorable (for an offense such as rape or murder). Note that those Honorably Discharged or receiving a General discharge typically transferred to that service branch’s reserves. The DD Form 217AF indicates the person is being discharged from the Air Force.

3. Selective Service Data

Look for the individual’s Selective Service Number (which the government used for draft purposes), along with where the individual registered. No date of induction indicates voluntary enlistment.

4. Service Data

This expansive section includes the date and location for entry into service, termination date for reserve duty and home address. You’ll also find the individual’s operative specialty(ies), service statement dates (including any foreign service time), and any decorations/awards or wounds received. You’ll also see any schools, colleges or training.

5. VA Data and Authentication

Here, you’ll find any information concerning life insurance allotment, plus final details for the discharge or separation.

A version of this portion of the article appeared in the December 2019 issue of Family Tree Magazine.

Monday, March 14, 2022

How to Preserve Old Letters

By Denise May Levenick
Old letters

Genealogists treasure handwritten letters because they reflect ancestors’ thoughts and experiences in their own words, on paper they handled. Correspondence provides a rare personal connection with ancestors. Whether you inherit Grandma’s missives or find your Civil War soldier’s last letter home in a public archive, here’s how to preserve these writings as part of your family history.

Q: How can I preserve a bundle of my grandfather’s letters to home when he was serving overseas during World War II? They’re in the original envelopes, wrapped with broken rubber bands.

A: Your collection is doubly valuable as a resource both for your family history and the country’s broader wartime history. As you take measures to preserve the letters, study them for news of friends and family that you can extract and confirm for your family tree. You’ll also want to read the letters for insight into the personality and everyday life of your grandfather and his buddies.

The durability of old documents depends on both the type of paper and the storage conditions. Paper made before around 1865 consists of cotton fibers, whereas most papers after that date are a combination of wood pulp and lignin. Lignin is the substance that makes your newspaper turn yellow in sunlight. In the late 19th century, stationery used for letter writing could be either type of paper.

Once you’ve investigated what type of paper they are written on, here are a few steps you can take to preserve your old letters:

  1. Work on a clean surface with freshly washed hands, and avoid handling the letters more than necessary.
  2. Remove and discard those failing rubber bands, which can leach chemicals that can harm your letters, but make note of how the letters are grouped. This may help you identify mysterious references to people and events a relative mentions having previously written about. If the paper is brittle and cracking, don’t force pages open. Instead, allow the loosely folded pages to sit undisturbed for a few hours. Often, the paper will absorb enough moisture from the air to relax and become easier to handle.
  3. Open the letters one at a time and remove any foreign objects, especially staples, straight pins or paper clips; these tend to rust and damage paper over time. Keep pages together in their original order by placing each letter with its envelope in an individual acid-free, lignin-free archival file folder. This type of storage material is available from a variety of archival suppliers, such as Hollinger Metal Edge and Archival Methods.
  4. Digitize the letters by scanning them on a flatbed scanner (scan the envelopes, too, if you have them) at a resolution of 300 dpi (dots per inch). Avoid sheet-fed scanners, which are fine for modern papers but can damage fragile heirloom documents. Use the digital versions for transcribing the letters and making copies to share; preserve the original letters in your home archive.
  5. Store the folders upright in a metal filing cabinet or acid-free archival document box located in an area of your home with consistent temperature and relative humidity. A closet on an inside wall is ideal.

More Letter Preservation Tips

A numbering system can help you keep track of which letters were bundled together and in what order: You could label the outside of a file folder Bundle A, Letter 2, George Longworth to Bessie (Meyers) Longworth, 6 March 1942. Then organize folders chronologically by date, author or addressee, depending on your purpose and the size of your collection.

If you didn’t inherit your great-grandfather’s wartime letters, perhaps another descendant did. Family letters also may have ended up in a historical archive or library where researchers can view them. Use these tips to start your search for long-lost letters:

  • Identify ancestors who lived away from home due to military service, migration or some other reason. With whom might they have corresponded? Also note ancestors who were prominent community members. 
  • Query descendants of letter writers and potential recipients about any documents they’ve inherited. 
  • Google the names (be sure to try women’s maiden names) and hometowns of the above ancestors to find blog posts, website mentions or items for sale on eBay
  • Search catalogs and websites of archives and libraries in ancestral hometowns. Next, search for names of family, friends and neighbors who may have mentioned your family in their correspondence.
  • Search the National Union Catalog of Manuscript Collections through the Library of Congress portal. This catalog helps you find personal and family manuscript collections from throughout the United States.
  • Try to connect with others tracing your family. Look at images they’ve added to their trees. If your own family tree image gallery is bare, post a “teaser” image from your collection to encourage others to get in touch with you.

Thursday, March 10, 2022

What is a Collateral Relative and Why Do They Matter?

By Sharon DeBartolo Carmack
(Getty Images)

Q. I am a total novice as far as family trees go, and I need to know exactly what a “collateral descendant” is.

A. A collateral relative is any blood relative who is not your direct ancestor. So your ancestors are your parents, grandparents, great-grandparents, etc., and your collateral relatives are cousins, nieces, nephews, aunts, uncles, siblings, etc.

Here are three common research scenarios we may face and ways our collateral research can help solve them:

1. Where did an immigrant ancestor come from?

Say you have a great-great grandmother and you don’t know where she came from. No passenger lists or naturalization documents can be found. Eventually, you find a baptismal record for one of her children in the United States (not the record of the ancestor through whom you descend) that mentions both parents’ birthplace—including the name of the tiny town in Slovakia.

2. Who are a female ancestor’s parents?

A census record identifies an older man living with her to be her father, which reveals her maiden name. No other documentation on him can be found, but she is buried next to a man with her maiden surname. He was of age to be her brother. Researching the life of the man buried next to her reveals both of his parents’ name (in his SS-5 application). His mother’s will names all her surviving children—including that daughter.

3. What happened to my ancestor?

It’s not uncommon to have an older adult disappear from records without finding a death record to explain the disappearance. Following each child forward in the census and city directories eventually leads to her name (mis-indexed) in the household of her youngest daughter’s husband. They’re living across the state line from where you found her gravestone. That’s why you hadn’t found her death record or an obituary—she was living in an entirely different state than expected when she passed away.